Bain vs McKinsey: Decoding the Differences

Bain VS McKinsey

If you’re venturing into the consulting world, the Bain vs McKinsey debate is bound to catch your attention. These 2 firms dominate the consulting landscape as 2 of the 3 elite “MBB” firms (McKinsey, Bain, and BCG).

What distinguishes them from one another?

We’ll demystify the Bain vs McKinsey question and explore similarities and differences across topics such as culture, career path, compensation, and more. 

Understanding the nuances between Bain vs McKinsey will help you find the firm that aligns with your career goals and workstyle preferences!

In this article, we’ll discuss:

  • What these prestigious firms do
  • Similarities between Bain vs McKinsey
  • Differences between Bain vs McKinsey
  • Bain vs McKinsey: 4 key questions to help you determine which firm is a better fit for you

Let’s get started!

Overview of Bain vs McKinsey & What They Do

Bain & Company

Bain, the youngest of the MBB consulting firms, was founded by Bill Bain in 1973 following his departure from Boston Consulting Group. 

With its headquarters in Boston, Massachusetts, Bain operates 65 cities in 40 countries, providing strategic advice and solutions to organizations across a wide range of industries.

Bain’s customer-centric approach and focus on delivering impactful results have solidified its position among MBB firms. The firm is particularly known for its expertise in private equity consulting.

McKinsey & Company

Founded in 1926, McKinsey has been around the longest out of the MBB firms. It is also the largest MBB firm, with more than 130 offices. 

The firm’s range of consulting services includes strategy, operations, technology, and more, allowing it to provide tailored solutions to address complex business challenges. McKinsey has a reputation for delivering exceptional results and shaping industries with its strategic insights and data-driven approach.


Nail the case & fit interview with strategies from former MBB Interviewers that have helped 89.6% of our clients pass the case interview.

Similarities Between Bain vs McKinsey

Let’s look at why landing a consulting job at these prestigious firms is so coveted!

General Application Process

The application process at both firms is rigorous and designed to assess analytical thinking and problem-solving skills. Both firms conduct multiple rounds of case and behavioral interviews, where candidates are challenged to showcase their consulting skills.

Check out Our Ultimate Guide to Case Interview Prep to learn about the interview process. 

Work-Life Balance

It’s no secret that consultants work hard, often up to 50 to 60 hours per week. Additionally, travel commitments for client projects can result in lengthy commutes.

However, both Bain and McKinsey recognize the importance of work-life balance and are dedicated to meeting the needs of their employees. To support their consultants, these firms offer a variety of perks, such as covered meals, transportation stipends, and other benefits that aim to enhance the overall work-life balance.


Bain and McKinsey offer highly competitive compensation packages that reflect the value they place on the skills and expertise of their consultants. Their salaries are known for being among the highest in the consulting industry. 

Generally, Bain and McKinsey match each other salaries quite closely for new consultants entering after graduation or business school. There may be slight variations across office locations to account for differences in the cost of living.

Check out our Management Consultant Salary Report for more information.

Feedback and Professional Development

Feedback and mentorship play a vital role at both firms, fostering a culture of continuous growth. Consultants are encouraged to give their managers upward feedback and also receive traditional feedback. Peer-to-peer feedback is actively encouraged, creating a supportive environment that facilitates accelerated learning.

Exit Opportunities

After working for a few years, many consultants exit to leadership positions within corporations, explore entrepreneurship, or join private equity/venture capital firms. Additionally, opportunities exist in non-profit and social impact organizations, academia, and public sector roles. 

Some consultants looking for better work-life balance pursue internal roles at the firm. Others may transition to different consulting firms.

Alumni Network

Both Bain and McKinsey boast esteemed alumni networks that offer valuable connections and resources for career development. Having been established earlier, McKinsey has a more extensive alumni network. 

Bain has a distinguished list of alumni who have excelled in their careers. Notable Bain alumni include Mitt Romney, former Governor of Massachusetts and U.S. presidential candidate, and Susan Wojcicki, former CEO of YouTube.

Similarly, examples of McKinsey alumni are influential business leaders, such as Sheryl Sandberg, Former COO of Facebook and Founder of Lean In, and Sundar Pichai, CEO of Google.

Differences Between Bain vs McKinsey

Bain vs McKinsey

The benefits of working at Bain vs McKinsey are comparable, and either choice would greatly accelerate your career. When deciding between the 2 firms, consider the key differences and what fits you best.

Case Interview

While the application process for both firms is similar, the McKinsey Case Interview format differs from Bain’s.

McKinsey uses an interviewer-led approach, where the interviewer guides the candidate through the case with specific questions. This format allows the interviewer to actively shape the discussion and to evaluate the candidate’s problem-solving abilities. Bain, on the other hand, expects the interviewee to lead the case discussion.

Read our article on Interviewer vs Interviewee-Led Cases to learn more about the differences and how to prepare for each.

Staffing Model

Bain follows a home office staffing model, where consultants are primarily based in their home office and work on projects within that office. This model allows for strong team cohesion and deep expertise within specific regions or industries. Teams fly to client sites, but it is typically within the region.

In contrast, McKinsey embraces a one-firm mentality. Consultants have the opportunity to work with colleagues from different countries and offices, facilitating the exchange of expertise and perspectives. For example, a manager from the Toronto office could work with an analyst from Switzerland. Core training classes mix consultants from different offices and countries.

Let’s compare the 2 models:

Bain vs McKinsey The Differences


Bain has a high energy culture, combining hard work and fun. With a local staffing model, Bain fosters a more collegial culture where colleagues can truly get to know each other. The advantage of this model is that local teams have more opportunities for face-to-face interactions, allowing for deeper professional relationships and a genuine understanding of one another.

The firm values team events, social gatherings, office parties, and retreats as integral to the Bain experience, promoting connections, fostering relationships, and cultivating a vibrant atmosphere. A standout event is the Bain World Cup, where thousands of employees from around the globe come together for spirited sports competitions and celebrations.

Bain consultants live by the motto: “A Bainie never lets another Bainie fail.” When faced with challenges, they rally together, providing unwavering support and assistance. This collaborative spirit propels professional growth and defines the vibrant culture that sets Bain apart.

Let’s compare that to McKinsey.

Despite the fierce competition to join McKinsey, the internal culture prioritizes collaboration over cutthroat competition. Colleagues genuinely support and assist each other. Here, quotas do not limit promotions, allowing talent to rise based on merit and contribution. This collaborative spirit shines through in the way McKinsey consultants respond to client challenges, always ready to lend a helping hand.

What sets McKinsey apart is its commitment to operating as a global network, determined to “bring the best of McKinsey” to every client engagement. Consultants can tap into this vast network, reaching out to fellow McKinsey experts across offices, regardless of whether they’ve met before. This unique approach allows for the exchange of best practices, expertise, and insights, ensuring that McKinsey consistently delivers exceptional value to its clients. McKinsey truly embraces the “one firm” mentality, valuing the collective knowledge and expertise that spans borders.

Career Progression

Both Bain and McKinsey provide structured career paths for their consultants, with McKinsey potentially offering slightly faster progression in job titles, depending on the specific office. The roles and responsibilities at each firm align between titles of similar tenure, ensuring a consistent career trajectory for consultants.

Your professional development and performance will determine your roles and responsibilities in either firm.

As your career progresses, you can explore non-linear paths, including internal transfers to specialized practices.


4 Key Questions to Determine Whether Bain vs McKinsey is A Fit for You

Let’s go back to the TelCo market entry example from earlier. 

1. What are your goals within your consulting career?

Take a close look at your career goals and aspirations. Consider the industries and areas of focus that align with your interests and long-term objectives. 

Bain vs McKinsey have different strengths and expertise in various industries, so understanding which firm’s focus and industry strengths resonate with your goals can be a significant deciding factor. For example, if you have a strong interest in private equity consulting, Bain might be more appealing to you. If you want to specialize in improving clients’ operations, McKinsey’s operations practice may be better.

Additionally, take into account geography. McKinsey’s extensive office network provides more options for location preferences, whether being closer to family or having access to recreational activities like surfing or skiing.

2. What do you envision doing after your consulting career?

Look beyond your consulting tenure and contemplate your aspirations for the future. Consider the specific type of work or industry you aim to pursue after your consulting career. 

Ultimately, both Bain and McKinsey are highly prestigious firms that carry significant weight in any industry. Regardless of the path you choose, a successful few years at either firm will open numerous doors for you post-consulting.

3. What level of travel or global exposure do you want?

Consider whether you have a keen interest in assignments outside your home office. Some people thrive in the fast-paced, jet-setting lifestyle of constant travel, while others prefer a more localized approach with a better work-life balance.

4. Where have you found genuine connections?

Going to recruiting events and chatting with current consultants is the best way to figure out if you have a good cultural fit with Bain vs McKinsey. Your unique personality and communication style may align more closely with one firm or even a specific office.

Here are some tips on what you can ask during an exploratory chat:

  • Be genuinely interested and professional: Approach conversations with a genuine curiosity about the other person’s experiences and insights. Remember to respect their time, listen actively, and follow up with a thank-you message to maintain the relationship.
  • Ask about their role and projects: Inquire about the type of work they do, the industries they specialize in, and the projects they have been involved in. Get specific about their role instead of the general project scope.
  • Seek recruiting advice from junior consultants: They have recently completed the recruiting process and can give actionable tips to land the job.

– – – – – – –

In this article, we’ve covered:

  • What these firms do
  • What makes Bain vs McKinsey similar
  • Areas where Bain vs McKinsey are different
  • Key questions to ask yourself to decide whether Bain vs McKinsey aligns better with your career goals

Still have questions?

If you have more questions about Bain vs McKinsey, leave them in the comments below. One of My Consulting Offer’s case coaches will answer them.

Other people prepping for Bain vs McKinsey found the following pages helpful:

Help with Your Consulting Application

Thanks for turning to My Consulting Offer for info on the healthcare case interview. My Consulting Offer has helped 89.6% of the people we’ve worked with to get a job in management consulting. We want you to be successful in your consulting interviews too. For example, here is how Eva was able to get her offers from McKinsey and Bain.


Nail the case & fit interview with strategies from former MBB Interviewers that have helped 89.6% of our clients pass the case interview.

3 Top Strategies to Master the Case Interview in Under a Week

We are sharing our powerful strategies to pass the case interview even if you have no business background, zero casing experience, or only have a week to prepare.

We are excited to invite you to the online event.

Where should we send you the calendar invite and login information?